Monday, 23 October 2017 »  Login
in
»
Movies » I Am Legend Movie Review
I am at

I Am Legend Review

I Am Legend
Samrat Sharma / fullhyd.com
EDITOR RATING
6.0
Performances
Script
Music/Soundtrack
Visuals
NA
NA
NA
NA
Suggestions
Can watch again
NA
Good for kids
NA
Good for dates
NA
Wait to rent it
NA
To the utter disappointment of everyone in my comic-loving brotherhood, I absolutely adored Constantine, the surprisingly effective film direct by Francis Lawrence, heralding the advent of a director who knew setting a mood and character of a city. A unique worldview that he had was all that the film had going for it, and possibly the biggest reason Lawrence got slated to direct I Am Legend.

Not considering the previous adaptations - the poorly made yet cult-ish Last Man On Earth (1964) and the awful Omega Man (1971) - the seminal book by Richard Matheson is nothing but mood. It's a somber meditation of man and his excesses, while at the same time being a character study of loneliness, all of it neatly wrapped in a thriller. In the book, apocalypse survivor Robert Neville spends his time hunting the mutated monsters that are all that remains of humanity.

He realizes after a while that these creatures are not mindless, but it is him who is the monster for them, an anomaly they don't understand. It is that perspective shift that leads to one of the most memorable endings in literature.

In the film, that only vaguely resembles the book, we again have Robert Neville (Smith), this time in the middle of New York, hunting and gathering by day, trying to survive by night. He has trapped some of the freakish mutants in his lab, and desperately tries to look for a cure. In that, in being a mood piece, the film is surprisingly effective, and offers up a worldview that wholly resembles the mood that the book set out to create.

I was in awe of the parts of the film tying to establish the film's world, its inhabitants (Neville and his dog mostly), and the almost eerily silent audio design that helps us immerse in the world that we are in. The way that the animals have taken over the cities, reclaiming the jungle that was once theirs, is brilliant. The film is frugally edited, though the pacing of the scenes is there to immerse us, get close to us and then chill us. No flashy photography, no cuts that jump here to there, just pure unadulterated narrative.

What does not work at all about the film is the incongruent third act, which appears as if though the studio bigwigs pushed for a shock-and-awe approach with a CGI-heavy bent. Not only does this make the film fall flat on its nose, it robs it of its strongest elements of mood and pacing.

Screenwriters Akiva Goldsman and Mark Protosevich are to be blamed squarely for a third act that is completely in opposition to the beautiful novel, and also does its worst to shoehorn a new faux philosophy about the title. I won't tell you the new ending, but trust me it is no one that matters as much as the one in the book. The film only tentatively meditates on the loneliness of the character and the repercussions of that, never treating that as the central theme of the movie.

For his part Will Smith is in top form here, asked to carry a whole film by himself and managing to pull that off. While he still retains that star charisma that helps the film about one single person not be boring, he has managed to drop the cocksureness of his earlier characters, finally making that leap from movie star to serious actor.

Problem is that he is accorded antagonists that do not work except at the most base level. The first time he encounters the creatures is chillingly effective, but as the film progresses, the overt reliance on CGI kills their menace. The solid audio design is shunned for needlessly loud sound effects, again taking away from the mood that the film laboriously establishes.

I admired the courage of Lawrence and Smith, primarily the way they choose to depict Neville's loneliness as a mirror to the abandoned city. It is an affecting sight, but the overall tone of the film appears superimposed, and the theme becomes diluted with too much reliance on CGI. Lawrence is a smart director, and he lets Smith do his thing, which as it turns out, is a good thing, but his script and the studio's insistence to turn this into an explosion fest to sate the blockbuster thirst may ultimately doom the film.
Share. Save. Connect.
  EMAIL
  PRINT
  SAVE
I AM LEGEND SNAPSHOT
I Am Legend (english) reviews
USER RATING
8.4
48 USERS
RATE
Rating is quick and easy - try it!
  • Cast
    Will Smith, Alice Braga, Charlie Tahan, Salli Richardson, Willow Smith, Darrell Foster, April Grace, Dash Mihok, Joanna Numata, Samuel Glen
  • Music
    James Newton Howard
  • Director
    Francis Lawrence
  • Theatres
    Not screening currently in any theatres in Hyderabad.
I AM LEGEND USER REVIEWS
1 - 5 OF 5 COMMENTS
POSITIVE  |  NEGATIVE |  NEWEST  |  OLDEST  |  MOST HELPFUL  |  LEAST HELPFUL
USER RATING
8.4
48 USERS
Performances
Script
Music/Soundtrack
Visuals
NA
NA
NA
NA
Can watch again - NA
Good for kids - NA
Good for dates - NA
Wait to rent it - NA
Sekhar M on 20th Dec 2007, 10:38pm | Permalink
god ... hollywood is suffering from zombie mania
RATING
2
X Y on 19th Dec 2007, 4:43pm | Permalink
Junk movie. Mantra 100 times better than this.
RATING
2
Ramesh H on 19th Dec 2007, 7:30am | Permalink
Excellent Movie!!
RATING
10
S S on 17th Dec 2007, 2:30pm | Permalink
Rediff gave it 3 here 2.5. That means better critic ?? You talk about act 3 - (spoiler) what does a man do who has nothing to live for ?/He achieved what he wanted, the Issue was resolved? (spoiler end) You make an assumption that studio bosses pushed for CGI - I say that it follows the rules of a survival horror genre ,thats what makes the last act work. How would you show a aggressive human bordering on animal with superhuman strength...stroll in the park ? ALso, about Will Smith becoming an actor - He got Oscar Nominations for Ali and Pursuit of Happyness. Probably you were not in coma then. And Mr Editor - The audience in theatre in Hyderabad enjoyed the movie thoroughly. I could judge from the reaction. So please do not give that excuse to hide the flaws of your reviewers. Learn from your mistakes and improve. We still love the site enough and thus want to see it be the best. My rating is 3.5 - No option for that so putting 4. Take the criticism positively and improve the standards.
RATING
8
Movie Talkie on 15th Dec 2007, 3:26pm | Permalink
God, crap review. Samrat, why the hell you dont undergo written communication skills training.

Communicate to express.

Pathetic way of writing. Seriously.
RATING
2
LEAVE A COMMENT
fullhyd.com has 700,000+ monthly visits. Tell Hyderabad what you feel about I Am Legend!
Rate Movie
[no link to your name will appear, overriding global settings]
To preserve integrity, fullhyd.com allows ratings/comments only with a valid email. Your comments will be accepted once you give your email, and will be deleted if the email is not authenticated within 24 hours.
My name:

Dissatisfied with the results? Report a problem or error, or add a listing.
ADVERTISEMENT
SHOUTBOX!
ADVERTISEMENT
This page was tagged for
I Am Legend english movie
I Am Legend reviews
release date
Will Smith, Alice Braga
theatres list
Follow fullhyd.com on
© Copyright 1999-2009 LRR Technologies (Hyderabad), Pvt Ltd. All rights reserved. fullhyd, fullhyderabad, Welcome To The Neighbourhood are trademarks of LRR Technologies (Hyderabad) Pvt Ltd. The textual, graphic, audio and audiovisual material in this site is protected by copyright law. You may not copy, distribute, or use this material except as necessary for your personal, non-commercial use. Any trademarks are the properties of their respective owners. More on Hyderabad, India. Jobs in Hyderabad.