I don't believe the review, or some of the user comments. Arshad is probably one of the best things about this movie, and makes it work, as important as 'Allah ke bande' or 'Sajna', even. This is one of the best independent eforts to come out of bollywood, and sadly, has not done wonders to the actors' careers as it should have. It sure does have its minuses, but which movie doesn't? The whole point is, after having watched it, did it make me nit-pick on those? In my case, am happy to say, no. I went in thinking it was gonna be another pretentious effort (part II indeed), but was pleasantly surprised by the whole effort. Mridul vs Bips? :-). If only Bips took as much chances with her career as Mridul has done, it might be a fair comparison at that.
Pros: Screenplay, performances, music, structure
Cons: Cinematography, less-than-satisfying resolution