This dude's start is pretty promising in that it's more or less like his Dad's
was after three movies. Difference is, Dad then got a Prakash Mehra, and an
as-yet-unused angry young man theme. And these improved things for him, in a
way of speaking. Whether history will repeat will be known only after 2-3 more
movies, but, as of now, in evil Bollywood where the boys are swiftly separated
from the men, this dude, as Aerosmith would put it, looks like a lady.
The scion of a super-rich family with a business strength of twenty-five factories,
Seth Garewal (Amrish Puri) is a proud patrician. Unlike his jolly and affectionate
younger brother (Anupam Kher), family honor alone matters to this dictator who
assigns everybody in the family roles they must fit in to.
His rebellious daughter, Sahiba (Aishwarya Rai), does not fancy the conventional
bliss of an arranged marriage, and would rather pursue her studies. Not that
academic arena is less stifling than the familial space. In her hostel, she
witnesses a murder. On the run to escape the hoodlums, she realizes that now
she has nowhere to go. Thanks to her bua, everybody back home thinks
she has married on the sly, while to college she dare not go back. As she is
about to commit suicide, Captain Karan (Abhishek Bachchan), who had earlier
bashed up the goons chasing her, once again saves her. He takes her home, and
back it is to confinement within the family honor, though this time, Karan,
who the family assumes to be her husband, is there to share it.
Such stifling of a young woman's urge for freedom from family traditions, which
want her to be married off at eighteen, is what the film tantalizingly prises
open. In fact, time and again, the story returns to the way that women, loving
bahus to the commanding Dadima, are suppressed in the patriarchal
The focus wanders, though. So does the never-ending plot based on mistaken
identity. In this bhoolbhulaiyya of a loooong film, turning and twisting
like the winding, endless gallis near Charminar, we get to see everything
that a typical masala film can offer - patriotism, festivals, murder mystery,
business wars, and the inane fantasies of the hero and the heroine who explode
into the dance-n-song routine at the drop of anything they happened to lay their
And lost in this mish-mash of mushy to mucky (and really insufferable is Shakti
Kapoor as a comedian) is the stalwart effort of poor Abhishek Bachchan, who
tries his level best to prove his mettle across a varying range of emotions.
Dude needs more luck.
All this emotional (melo)drama is etched against the lush scenario of the color-rich
Punjab and its "diler" traditions. The film is a wonder of cinematography.
Every trick in the cameraman's textbook is used to enliven the vitality of the
ambience. From the slightly dusky, ethnicised beauty of Aishwarya and the colorful
"baraat" to the lyrical presentation of the futility of an intense
passion bound by family honor, the film is a riot of colors captured through
pretty unusual angles. The melodious songs provide another respite from the
story with its very filmy twists. The film shows how important editing is to
As for acting, the gold medal should go to the eye-twirling Amrish Puri, some
follower of Karate and Kung-fu who slaps everybody in sight right, left, center
despite the victim's age or status. Closely follows the gorgeous Aishwarya who,
when not weeping copiously, peeps from behind the all-protective lover boy,
giving him the dumbest look possible to convey her embarrassment, shrieking
her heart out all along to find out why he is so good that she cannot but love
him. The rest of the cast, including Anupam Kher, act out their supporting (character)
roles in a mawkish imitation of the wedding videos that the mid-90's superhits,
in the wake of Ham Aapke Hain Koun, were.
In brief, this supposedly family-viewing film is a missed and wasted chance
to have depicted precisely either a young girl's dilemmas, caught as she is
in her family's true love for her that complicates her situation, or a thorough
gentleman's search for true love.