Tuesday, 26 November 2024 »  Login
in
»
Movies » Stalin Movie Review
I am at

Stalin Review

Stalin
EDITOR RATING
6.0
Performances
Script
Music/Soundtrack
Visuals
NA
NA
NA
NA
Suggestions
Can watch again
NA
Good for kids
NA
Good for dates
NA
Wait for OTT
NA
Grab this: Sunil stops his dance in the middle of the opening song of Andala Ramudu to salute a Chiranjeevi poster along the way, and breaks into adulatory prose about "annayya". Lawrence dedicates Style to unabashedly singing paens of Chiranjeevi. Venkatesh, a huge star himself, spends half his time on stage at Richard Gere’s AIDS initiative at the Lalitha Kala Thoranam, praising Chiranjeevi who is to come later.

And for newer actors in smaller films, it seems de riguer to refer to the "Mega Star" in some way. From Uday Kiran to Navdeep and Sai Kiran and, of course, Allu Arjun, they have all done it. And finally, there are whole movies with titles like Seenugaadu Chiranjeevi Fan. And a film just out called Dongodi Pelli introduces its hero as "real Chiranjeevi fan, Rajendra Prasad".

Yes, Tollywood continuously makes Chiranjeevi almost mythical. It's a virtuous cycle - they are playing to the masses who love him, and all the references make him bigger. And a whole film casting him then becomes almost too good to be true. So when a new one is out after several months, it is not just a movie – it is meeting a need. It is the real thing.

So it’s hard to say if you will like Stalin. To understand that, try answering this: would the feeling of being in the Sanctum Sanctorum at Tirupati be the same if you could just stroll in and out whenever you wanted, as opposed to the effort of being in an 8-hour queue now? The hype and the long wait themselves enhance the experience.

Take Chiranjeevi out of it, and Stalin is a below-average drama. But you cannot take Chiranjeevi out of Stalin, for Stalin is not a movie that casts an actor. It is 3 hours of Chiranjeevi. Just as you do not compare apples with oranges, you do not compare Stalin with movies.

Stalin comes at a time when Chiranjeevi has had 2 average films in the last 2 years and just 2 hits in 5 years after Indra in 2002 (Tagore and Shankardada MBBS). The Chiranjeevi fever appears to be at an all-time high. It obviously has something to do with 9 months of all-hype and no-Chiranjeevi. That factor itself may help the film be a hit, even if very few will return to theaters to watch this a second time.

Stalin (Chiranjeevi) is an ex-Army Major, who quits the Army for certain reasons and settles down to social service in Hyderabad. He helps handicapped people write exams, he saves young girls from the flesh trade, and he helps couples in love get married. He has just one request of people he’s helped – that they pass the favor forward. They should in return help 3 others, and ask those 3 to help 3 others.

One day he roughs up some goons who hurt a beggar girl, and that snowballs into a huge issue which puts him in direct confrontation with the home minister himself. However, Stalin is all-powerful, and needs no brains to handle the crisis – he can just beat up any number of goons. The last fight sees him single-handedly beat up about 200 (no exaggeration) armed and well-built goons. The last people we knew capable of that lived circa 3000BC, and all fought in the Mahabharata war.

He then lands in hospital due to an injury he sustained while in the Army that’s aggravated now, and lakhs of people turn up to pray for him when they realize (through TV channels) that he is the one who started the 3 favors movement, which has spread across the state. Needless to say, he lives.

Stalin is a well-intentioned film, but suffers on structure and logic. Chiranjeevi has huge mass-following, and it is quite commendable that he is trying to use that to spread good. But wanting to spread good is not an end in itself – the execution needs thought for the effort to work to the greatest extent possible.

As a film, Stalin is much lesser than a professional effort. The film tries to be both a Rudraveena and a mass-potboiler at the same time, and can deliver on neither. The screenplay is poor, there is too much craving to have all the formula elements, there is too much preaching in the first half, the choice of heroine is disastrous and there are gaps of logic beyond even movie standards.

The movie has a mother-daughter fracas, a completely half-baked romantic angle, a hero vs. super-villian theme, an Army Indo-Pak war flashback, a social thread, a comic track, and 6 songs (including an item song, but no Nenu Saitam), thus trying to be something for everyone.

Then, the first half-hour is poorly written and too preachy – it assumes the audiences stopped growing up in 1960. A hero doesn’t tell people to be good or bitch that they are not – he just sets personal example.

Mistakes abound - like when a handicapped (handless) girl who goes outside the gate of a college in Uppal to ask passersby for help to write a test, but is doing that at Nagarjuna Circle on Banjara Hills (yes, we all know it is 5 minutes’ walking distance), and is back in 10 minutes in the classroom at Uppal.

Or when this girl commits suicide just because she cannot get someone to write a test for her – when she can always take that test again in a few months. She's strong enough to live with a crippling handicap like that, but resorts to the supreme step for a much lesser reason like this.

Or where Stalin has a very old heart problem that will aggravate when he gets over-stressed, but which hurts only in the end, even if he has been in many similarly difficult situations all through the film.

This is a Chiranjeevi film, and they have access to all the money in the world – couldn’t they care for the small things?

The fights are much outside even movie standards – be they the one in a 6-floor mall where Stalin beats up some 20 armed goons by the time a lift reaches the top floor (normally 20 seconds), or the one at the end where he cripples (repeat) 200 people. Stalin is just Superman, and doesn’t show any intelligent handling when confronted with difficult situations – he will just beat up as many people as you can send.

Trisha has a cumulative of 10 minutes in the film outside of the songs. She’s talented, and a coffee shop scene is quite well-enacted, but whosever brilliant idea it was to pair Trisha with Chiranjeevi should be given a special Nandi this year for creative casting.

There is no other performance that gets much scope – this is a Chiranjeevi film. So Sunil, Khushboo, Sarada are all dwarved. The songs are just average. There are some dialogues that really kick you, but they are few and far between.

What works for Stalin is the ending - where a crowd of a couple of lakhs turns up at the hospital to pray for him. It moves you, and might make you forget all the flaws and speak positively.

Chiranjeevi is an exceptionally talented actor who increasingly puts himself in the hands of exceptionally inept scriptwriters and directors who can spell the word "formula", and nothing much else. Their brief seems to be, he has an image, write scripts to suit that. What formula films do Rajnikanth, Mamooty, Kamal Hasan, Aamir Khan or SRK do? They’re all 40+.

Chiranjeevi hasn’t had a single standard mass movie that’s been a hit since Indra – Tagore and Shankardada, the only hits, were unconventional scripts. The lesson is clear – mass films aren’t working, and younger directors and avant garde scripts deserve a chance with him.

On the whole, Stalin might have been a landmark film with more focus, thought, and care for small things. It still has the potential to impact several people, simply because of Chiranjeevi’s reach and appeal.

And what's with the names, by the way? Stalin had some 14 million people killed. And Hitler, 6 million people. Let's hope Chiru's next film is called Mandela.
Share. Save. Connect.
  EMAIL
  PRINT
  SAVE
STALIN SNAPSHOT
Stalin (telugu) reviews
USER RATING
6.0
664 USERS
RATE
Rating is quick and easy - try it!
  • Cast
    Chiranjeevi, Trisha, Sarada, Khushboo, Prakash Raj, Sunil, Pradeep Rawat, Riaz Khan, L B Sriram, Brahmanandam
  • Music
    Mani Sharma
  • Director
    A Muruga Doss
  • Theatres
    Not screening currently in any theatres in Hyderabad.
STALIN USER REVIEWS
61 - 75 OF 85 COMMENTS  |  FIRST  |  PREVIOUS  |  NEXT  |  LAST
POSITIVE  |  NEGATIVE |  NEWEST  |  OLDEST  |  MOST HELPFUL  |  LEAST HELPFUL
USER RATING
6.0
664 USERS
Performances
Script
Music/Soundtrack
Visuals
NA
NA
NA
NA
Can watch again - NA
Good for kids - NA
Good for dates - NA
Wait for OTT - NA
Keerthi on 22nd Sep 2006, 12:51am | Permalink
Good movie, good message
RATING
8
Venkat Kishore Ryakala on 21st Sep 2006, 11:20pm | Permalink
This movie sucked So hard, i got a nose bleed watching it. This is the last thing i write b4 i scoop my eyeballs out. WHAT the holy hell is this film industry of ours coming to when the so-called big films can't stop pandering to the basest of our needs even when making what is attempted to be a socially poignaant piece?? I agree that chiru is a good actor (no pacino, but thats just me probably)..but this meaningless holier than thou tripe that glorifies this very real, very aged man, has to stop. When will chiru pull a bachchan-esque reinvention montage which MIGHT just begin with quitting dancing with girls who're his daughters age? When will we see a good movie with great acting: or is that no longer what escapist cinema has come to stand for? When, dudes and dudettes, WHEN???
RATING
2
Deepa on 21st Sep 2006, 10:44pm | Permalink
wat a movie! just superb.
RATING
8
Sreenu on 21st Sep 2006, 9:35pm | Permalink
Message is good..but movie is bad.. very bad... If you want to pass good message choose some other medium and do it for free.. With your (Chiru) influence you can do it thru TV or News papers.. Why do you make people to spend money on this BS movie..

One guy spend $1116 for one ticket .. It wud have been very good if he cud spend it for a good cause..

Please dont waste your time and money on this BS movie
RATING
2
Shekhar on 21st Sep 2006, 9:08pm | Permalink
HI,



I dont want to talk much about the movie.. but just want to help others (concept of this movie).. I want to help 3 people.. so I am telling you people who have all not watched yet, please do not watch this movie.. and please help 3 more people by passing this messg....
RATING
2
Chandra Sekhar Cherupally on 21st Sep 2006, 8:46pm | Permalink
In short, Stalin whole movie is a BS.. Hope you guys understand what is BS..
RATING
2
Sanjeev on 21st Sep 2006, 7:39pm | Permalink
One of the best movies in Chiru's career (Take away some comercial elements)....

One of the worst reviews by your site....
RATING
10
Vinay on 21st Sep 2006, 7:01pm | Permalink
big bore
RATING
2
ESCI on 21st Sep 2006, 6:49pm | Permalink
Your review is totally based on Emotions VS Logic, where the latter predominated. One cannot apply logic on everything. After all film delivers message to render help to others,which is worth to be followed. One cannot beat hundreds, which can never be done too, pumps blood into vessels of audience in the filght of good and bad. I can say the reviewer is silimar to guy commented on suicided girl. Beyond every thing, these kind of films should be encouraged..irrespective of the hero.
RATING
8
Xxx Xxx on 21st Sep 2006, 5:23pm | Permalink
why the reviewer is looking for somuch of logic in movies. do people sing and dance in real life, and that too in foreign locations?? is there a logic behind it? but this is there in every movie
RATING
10
O..K on 21st Sep 2006, 3:26pm | Permalink
O..K cinema is not good. We agree with fullhyd. But what is this review... Why the reviewer need logic in the movies.
RATING
4
Ram on 21st Sep 2006, 3:20pm | Permalink
Movie is average.See after 15 days b'coz after 15 days tickets rates will be normal and everybody get the tickets freely.

Message is good

Fights and Graphics are worst

Songs are average..Only two are good.

Direction is bad.

Chiru also tooo fat
RATING
4
A K on 21st Sep 2006, 3:16pm | Permalink
Chiru's fans number is more than any other hero in telugu.

Moral of the Movie is excellent but screenplay and story are average.It could be superb hit if directory narrates the story directly.So many unnecessary fights,graphics(jumping from one car to another car,beating 300..

Do you think that Chiru needs all this waste thinks..

It may be average by the end of day.
RATING
6
Truth on 21st Sep 2006, 2:56pm | Permalink
I am big fan of Chiranjeevi when he acts and when the script is good. This one is a dumb movie and sucks. Makes you feel that you have insulted and humiliated your own intellect by spending so much money and time on watching this movie.



I will probably never watch any "mass" Chiru's movie again.
RATING
2
Keshav Naidu on 21st Sep 2006, 1:11pm | Permalink
the title is meant for villains not for killing innocents.
RATING
10
61 - 75 OF 85 COMMENTS  |  FIRST  |  PREVIOUS  |  NEXT  |  LAST
LEAVE A COMMENT
fullhyd.com has 700,000+ monthly visits. Tell Hyderabad what you feel about Stalin!
Rate Movie
[no link to your name will appear, overriding global settings]
To preserve integrity, fullhyd.com allows ratings/comments only with a valid email. Your comments will be accepted once you give your email, and will be deleted if the email is not authenticated within 24 hours.
My name:

Dissatisfied with the results? Report a problem or error, or add a listing.
ADVERTISEMENT
SHOUTBOX!
{{todo.name}}
{{todo.date}}
[
]
{{ todo.summary }}... expand »
{{ todo.text }} « collapse
First  |  Prev  |   1   2  3  {{current_page-1}}  {{current_page}}  {{current_page+1}}  {{last_page-2}}  {{last_page-1}}  {{last_page}}   |  Next  |  Last
{{todos[0].name}}

{{todos[0].text}}

ADVERTISEMENT
This page was tagged for
Stalin andarivadu movie Review 123telugu
stalin andarivadu movie story
stalin andarivadu movie review 123telugu
stalin andrivadu review123
stalin andarivadu review
Follow fullhyd.com on
Copyright © 2023 LRR Technologies (Hyderabad) Pvt Ltd. All rights reserved. fullhyd and fullhyderabad are registered trademarks of LRR Technologies (Hyderabad) Pvt Ltd. The textual, graphic, audio and audiovisual material in this site is protected by copyright law. You may not copy, distribute or use this material except as necessary for your personal, non-commercial use. Any trademarks are the properties of their respective owners.